INHERITANCE ANOMALY OF DAUGHTER “BATANG ANGKOLA” BASED ON ISLAMIC LAW AND COMMON LAW

: This study aimed to determine and analyze the distribution of Angkola customary inheritance to daughters. The type of research was field research, with a qualitative descriptive method, and the approach used legal sociology and a state approach. In contrast, the data types used consisted of primary and secondary data. The findings were that the kinship system used by the Angkola tribe in the distribution of inheritance adheres to a patrilineal kinship system, so with this patrilineal system, the position and inheritance rights of daughters are not recognized by Angkola custom. Even though they are not classified as heirs, daughters can still get a share of their parent's inheritance utilizing Olong Ate, namely giving love from a brother to his sister without a nominal amount. With the concept of Olong Ate, the share received by Daughter cannot be determined; the share for Daughter may be less, more, or equal to the share for boys. If Daughter's share is equal to or bigger than the boys, then there is a clash between Angkola customary and Islamic inheritance laws.


Introduction
Five recognized legal systems in the world are still being implemented and developed. 1Some of the systems in question are the Comment Law system; countries that adhere to this legal system are the United Kingdom and the countries that were once colonized, which is currently generally joined in the Commonwealth of Nations.Second, the Civil Law system originated from Roman law.It was adopted by Continental Western European countries and brought to several of its former colonies by the former Western colonial governments.Third, the customary law system in several Asian and African countries.Fourth, the Islamic legal system, adherents of this legal system are all Muslims wherever they are, whether it is an Islamic state or a country whose population is not only Muslim.And Fifth, the Communist/Socialist legal system was implemented in several communist/socialist countries. 2ndonesia adheres to three of the five legal systems described above.The three legal systems in question are the civil law system, Islamic law, and customary law.The State of Indonesia explains and emphasizes that Indonesia is a rule-of-law country with these three systems following what is stated in Article 1, paragraph (3) of the 1945 Constitution.The distinctive character of the civil law system is the form of laws or regulations that are written (recorded).) and civil law regulations developed in Indonesia since the Dutch colonial period and persist today.Even though more or less 72 years ago, the Dutch colonial period had ended, it did not rule out the possibility that the regulations that had been created were not being enforced at this time in Indonesia.. 3 Inheritance is one of the objects whose law and distribution procedures have been determined by the three legal systems above. 4The problem that often arises in society regarding inherited objects is the process of dividing them.In Indonesia, the distribution of inheritance can be done in three ways.First, referring to Islamic law; second, to civil law from the Dutch colonial legacy (Hukum Burgelijk Wetboek / BW ); and Third, to the provisions that apply to the customs of each ethnicity or tribe.So it is not surprising that the practice of dividing inheritance in a way other than the stipulations of Islamic law has often occurred in Indonesia. 5s practised by the Angkola indigenous people occurred in the South Tapanuli Regency area.In this case, the author limits and takes case examples from the scope of the Angkola indigenous people in Batang Angkola District.The Angkola indigenous people believe in customary law as the right means to distribute inheritance or inheritance.The kinship system used by the Angkola tribe adheres to a patrilineal kinship system, meaning that the lineage system is followed according to the father's line.The position of men is much more prominent than that of women. 6n the traditional Angkola culture, the term Olong Ate is known, which is used when dividing the inheritance, meaning that it is a gift from a brother to a sister to show affection. 7There are no customary provisions governing how large a portion must be given by a brother to his sister, but the type of gift is usually in the form of property that may be used for the rest of his life. 8n the conventional inheritance system of Angkola and South Tapanuli, Daughter cannot get a share whose distribution process follows the rules of heirs or is not classified as an heir. 9This is because the existence of the daughter is traditionally no longer in her father's house but has moved as a whole to the extended family of her husband. 10Unless there is a deviation in a family, 11 daughters have the right to become heirs. 12The deviation in question is if the heir does not have sons. 13esearch on the inheritance of the of Surah An-Nisa Verses 11, 12 and 176).The findings in this study indicate that the Angkola Batak Muslim community adheres to a patrilineal kinship system; namely, the lineage is taken from the male side.Then at the distribution of inheritance, men have a more dominant role than women.So, male heirs control almost all of the inheritance, while female heirs only get a share in gifts from the group of male heirs.Furthermore, the heirs often delay dividing the inheritance if one of the parents is still alive. 14Meanwhile, the Qur'an, as the main guideline for Islamic inheritance law, is present by giving portions to each heir following the provisions of Allah SWT, namely with provisions on the portion size that is not based on early and large age.Then strictly Islamic inheritance law stipulates that every time there is a death, a determination of the share of each heir must be carried out. 15ased on the explanation above, this research differs from previous research using the Al-Qur'an perspective.At the same time, this research uses two approaches: Islamic law and customary law.The inheritance of the Olong Ate custom is a rule that is believed by the Angkola custom and enforced to obtain the share of inheritance for daughters, so here the author is very interested in further researching the inheritance cases of daughters that occurred in Batang Angkola District.

Literature Review
The customary inheritance legal system is influenced by societal patterns and forms, which are based on genealogical and territorial factors. 16 In Islam, there is only one inheritance system, namely the bilateral one.Islamic inheritance law regulates the transfer of property from someone who has died to someone still alive. 19Various names call these rules regarding the transfer of property.In the Islamic legal literature, several terms are found to name inheritance laws, such as Faraid, Fiqh Mawaris, and legal inheritance. 20he form of inheritance or inheritance according to Islamic law is very different from the form of inheritance according to Western law as regulated in BW and customary inheritance law. 21According to Islamic law, inheritance is "several properties and all the rights of those who died in a clean condition".And other payments caused by the death of the heir".

Method
The type of research that the authors use is field research with a qualitative descriptive method, 23 namely 24 the data that researchers obtain from the field will be examined and analyzed again to produce factual data for this study. 25The approach used is the sociology of law (Socio-Legal) 26 and statutory approach (State Approach). 27n determining an informant using the purposive sampling technique. 28The informants in this study are; Traditional Leaders, Religious Leaders, and the Community of Batang Angkola District.The data type used consisted of primary data from research informants through interviews and observation and secondary data from the Batang Angkola sub-district office, books, journals, and other supporting data.The location of this research is in the Batang Angkola sub-district with a focus on the Angkola ethnic group, whose distribution is quite wide, making it easier for researchers to extract data that is appropriate to the research problem. 29The object of this research is the inheritance of the Angkola indigenous daughter.In contrast, the research subject is the Angkola indigenous people, who are directly involved in the distribution of inheritance..

Inheritance Rights of Daughter in Islamic Law
In the past, among the Pre-Islamic Jahiliyah, not only in the Arabian Peninsula, 30 they did not give inheritance to women and children (both men and women) at all, but only gave an inheritance to the male line with the male record.has matured and his strength can be relied upon in fighting on the battlefield. 31To renew the customary law of Pre-Islamic ignorance, 32 the Koran lowered several verses regarding inheritance and one of the inheritance verses referred to is in surah an-Nisa verse 7. 33 The background to the revelation of this verse is following the existing history regarding the case of Aus bin Thabit al-Ansari. 34He was a war hero of Uhud who died leaving several heirs, namely; one wife (Ummu Kahah/Kuhlah), two younger brothers (Arjafah/Arfajah, and Suwa'id) are the uncle of the children of Aus, and three daughters.Following the customary law of Arab Jahiliyah inheritance, only his two younger siblings are entitled to inherit Aus' property, while his wife and three children are not entitled to a share of his inheritance. 35eeing the injustice in obtaining this inheritance, Umm Kahah (Aus' wife) fought for her women's rights by advocating for the Prophet Muhammad.He told all the sadness and injustice that was felt. 36Starting from the absence of inheritance rights for him, especially for his three daughters, who are still Daughters, even at an early age.Upon Umm Kahah's complaint, the Prophet summoned Suwaid and Arjafah to ask about this.They answered the Apostle "that those who are entitled to receive an inheritance are only male heirs who can find food and face the battlefield, while they (Um Kahah and her three daughters) are unable to carry weapons in war".For the answers given by Suwaid and Arjafah, he received a revelation in this case that Allah revealed the verse of the Koran in Surah an-Nisa verse 7. 38 The revelation of this verse abolished (Mansukh) the customary inheritance law of ignorance as explained above.So this is where the role of Islamic law is seen as a guard in taking away the inheritance rights of daughters to the inheritance of their parents. 39fter the verses of the Koran regarding inheritance were revealed, the provisions regarding inheritance distribution received great attention because inheritance distribution often had unfavourable consequences. 40So that the parts of the inheritance which are the rights of the heirs are determined in detail in the Qur'an properly, wisely, and fairly. 41his provision relates to the transfer of property belonging to a person left after death to his heirs, whether the heirs are male or female.The provisions regarding inheritance law are based on QS An-Nisa' (4) paragraph 11: 42 Economic Perspective," Journal of Nusantara Economy 1, no. 1 (December 10, 2022): 14-28.
Meaning: Allah prescribes (obliges) you regarding (the distribution of inheritance for) your children, (namely) the share of a son is equal to the share of two daughters.If the children are all Daughter with more than two in number, their share is two-thirds of the assets left behind.If she (the daughter) is only one, she gets half (the property left behind).For both parents, each share is onesixth of the assets left behind, if he (the deceased) has children.If he (the deceased) has no children and he is inherited by both parents (only), his mother gets one-third.If he (the deceased) had several brothers, his mother got one-sixth.(The inheritance is divided) after (fulfilled) the will he made or (and paid off) the debt.(About) your parents and your children, you do not know which of them is of more benefit to you.This is Allah's decree.Verily, Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise.
The explanation of the verse above states that Allah determines the division of inheritance into three groups: boys, Daughters, and a mix of boys and daughters. 43Besides the above verses, Koranic verses related to Islamic inheritance law are found in QS.An-Nisa (4) verses 7, 8, 12, 33, 176, 180,  and   44 The hadith also explains the inheritance of daughters.The hadith was narrated by Ibn Mas'ud which reads; It means: Prophet, peace be upon him.Set 1/2 for daughters and 1/6 for granddaughters (from sons) to complement the 2/3 part, the rest for sisters.
According to A. In his book Al-Fara'id, Hasan clearly explained the provisions regarding the portion of inheritance for daughters according to their circumstances.The details are shown in the table below.Based on the explanation, along with the legal basis for inheritance as described above, provides concrete evidence of the position and rights of daughters as the heirs  However, what distinguishes it is that the share that daughters get is smaller than that of boys.In short, Islamic law explains that the share of one son is equal to that of two daughters 46 According to the majority of scholars, there are 3 reasons why someone inherits the property of someone who has died, namely, kinship, marriage, and wala'. 47The Malikiyah and Syafi'iyah scholars gave an additional reason to obtain inheritance rights, namely the Islamic path (Islamic relations). 48In addition to the causes of inheritance, Islamic law also regulates several causes that cancel or prevent an heir from being entitled to his inheritance rights. 49Factors that can hinder inheritance are actions or things that invalidate a person's right (heir) to receive an inheritance and the causes and conditions for inheriting.Three things can hinder inheritance in Islam, agreed by the jurists: murder, religious differences, and slavery. 50

Inheritance Rights of Angkola Indigenous Daughter
The Angkola tribe, or Angkola Batak, is one of the largest tribes in the Angkola area, South Tapanuli, and the Padangsidimpuan city area, North Sumatra Province.called Batang Angkola, it means one of the names of the sub-districts in South Tapanuli Regency, namely Batang Angkola District.Batang Angkola District is one of 15 Districts in South Tapanuli Regency.Batang Angkola District is Main District whose formation has existed since Tapanuli Regency South is formed.According to the data the researchers obtained in 2021, Batang Angkola District consists of 21 villages and most Angkola Customs adhere to Islam. 51he Angkola Indigenous People are wellknown for the thickness of their customs and religion.The community also highly upholds Islamic values in everyday life.Many Islamic education and study institutions established within the region's scope and outside the Batang Angkola District area clearly show that the Angkola indigenous people are diligent about their religious rules.
The obedience of the Angkola indigenous people to religion does not defeat obedience to the customary rules that apply to them.As indigenous peoples in general, the Angkola indigenous people also have rules for transferring ownership of inherited assets to their heirs.All heirs in Angkola customary law are relatives of the men as in the patrilineal kinship system.Following Angkola customary rules, the heirs who are entitled to receive the inheritance are; 1) The heir's male offspring, 2) The heir's father, 3) The heir's father's brother, 4) The heir's grandfather, 5) The heir's father's brother, 6) The ancestors, clan, and as big as the heir, 7) Huta (Village). 52hereas daughters do not have the slightest right to inheritance, even though they can get a share of the property, the property received is not an inheritance but a gift from a brother (brother or sister) to his sisters.Giving inheritance like this, the local indigenous people call it Olong ate, which means giving to show affection.The amount given to the sister is not stipulated by customary law, but the gift from the brother to the sister must be in the form of property that can be used for the rest of his life. 53r. Inggou Daulay 54 explained that according to the Angkola traditional belief, the reason a Daughter is not entitled to receive the inheritance of their parents or is not classified as an heir is because one day a Daughter will marry a man of her choice, after marriage, the lineage of the daughter who starts at the beginning of her lineage will switch to her parents then turned to her husband.So that the husband, who has the right to be responsible physically and spiritually, is not his parents.
The same matter was also explained by one of the older traditional leaders in the area, that following the customary law in force, the distribution of inheritance fell only to sons and not to daughters.Suppose a daughter insists on asking for a share of the inheritance from her parents.In that case, the customary sanctions set by the local Angkola indigenous people will apply, namely that the daughter will be excluded from her family lineage according to custom. 55 applicable Angkola customary sanctions the daughter must be expelled from the inheritance house with no respect.Because actually, the parental inheritance house is a part for the youngest son, which may not be handed over to anyone, especially to daughters, whether they are the oldest child, middle child, or youngest child. 56

Analysis of Angkola Traditional Anomaly Study Practices in Barang Angkola District
The Angkola indigenous people who live in the Batang Angkola sub-district, in particular, are a group of people who obey all legal regulations that apply in their area, be it religious law regulations, customary law, and also positive law.As we know that people who live in rural areas are usually people who are still strong in their customary rules. 57ccording to the Angkola indigenous people who live in Batang Angkola District, inheritance is an object whose distribution process is still under the auspices of customary law.Olong Ate is a term the Angkola custom uses to obtain a daughter's share of the inheritance.Even though the position of a daughter is not recognized as an heir, with Olong Ate, the daughter gets a share of her parent's inheritance.
The side of the conflict between the customary rules of Angkola and Islamic law is the customary provisions that decide that daughters are not heirs.This decision seemed to go back to the pre-Islamic era of ignorance, which did not recognize daughters as heirs and seemed to contradict Islamic rules, which were written in the Koran Surah An-Nisa verses 7 and 11.The contents of these verses explain the position and rights of a daughter as an heir. 58he Compilation of Islamic Law as a collection of Islamic law written and compiled regularly and enforced in Indonesia also strengthens the position and rights of Daughters as heirs.It coincides with Article 174, which explains the groups of heirs, which consist of blood and marriage relations.According to the blood relationship, the first is from the male group (father, son, brother, uncle, and grandfather), and the second is from the female group (mother, Daughter, sister, and grandmother).Furthermore, Article 176 KHI explains the amount of the share that a daughter heir obtains. 59ollowing the contents of the article that the share of the Daughter, if there is only one, is 1/2 if two Daughters or more, then get 2/3 together, and if the Daughter is with boys then the share of boys is 2:1 with the Daughter. 60aw then the distribution must match the nominal value.While the division of inheritance in this area is still in the form of objects, it is difficult if the inheritance distribution is adjusted according to the actual faraidh law.However, in practice, men's share is more than women's, and there must be a sense of agreement with the heirs.This is because the Batang Angkola subdistrict division still uses customary law.If the inheritance is a rupiah, the distribution will be carried out using faraidh law.If the type of inheritance is in the form of objects or goods, then the distribution must follow applicable customary law. 61eaders and traditional leaders.Where if the conclusion is drawn from the explanation of the religious leaders of Batang Angkola Sub-District that the distribution of inheritance in the area does use not only customary law but also applies faraidh law.Faraidh law is used if the inheritance is in the form of a rupiah, and the distribution is according to customary law if the inheritance is in the form of objects.Moreover, the researcher also concluded that daughters have rights and position as heirs with the sentence put forward by a religious figure "that the share of sons must be greater than that of daughters".62 Contrary to what traditional leaders and some community members conveyed, the researchers obtained data through interviews.The division of inheritance in the Batang Angkola sub-district still uses customary law.The name that applies to the Angkola custom is "Olong Ate," which means the gift of affection a brother gives to his sister.A daughter is not allowed to play a role when her brothers distribute her parents' inheritance because the daughter's share will be given after the brothers have finished discussing the distribution.63 From the counter perspective between traditional leaders and religious leaders in Batang Angkola Subdistrict, the researcher can draw a finding that the invalidity of the position and rights of daughters in the distribution of Angkola customary inheritance is not merely not getting a share of the inheritance inherited from their parents.The daughter still gets a share that comes from the share of each side of her brother, which is set aside and then given to her sister.Even though they call this gift a form of a man's love for his sister, the property that a daughter receives is an inheritance from her parents.As if the term Olong Ate in the Angkola custom is a qiasan for mentioning daughters' inheritance.64 If olong ate a way of obtaining a daughter's share of the inheritance, it is not certain whether the share received by the daughter is less or more, or it could be equal to the son's share.So that the concept of olong ate applied by the Angkola custom can have a legal influence on the inheritance of Islamic law.65 Following the provisions of Islamic law written in the Koran as a source of Islamic law and the KHI as a guideline for Islamic law in Indonesia, the proportion of male children is greater than that of female children, which, when compared, becomes 2:1.So that if the division of Angkola's ancestral inheritance using the concept of olong ate allows for a shift in the provisions of Islamic inheritance law with the 2:1 provision..

Conclusion
The Angkola indigenous people who live in the Batang Angkola sub-district, in particular, are a group of people who obey all legal regulations that apply in their area, be it religious law regulations, customary law, and also positive law.The people of Batang Angkola sub-district still use customary law to divide an inheritance.Olong Ate is a term used by the Angkola custom to obtain a daughter's share of the inheritance, even though the position daughter is not recognized as an heir.However, with Olong Ate, the daughter gets a share of the inheritance left by her parents.
The customary provisions of Angkola, which apply Olong Ate as a way of obtaining the inheritance share of daughters, cannot be determined whether the share received by daughters is less, more, or maybe equal to that of sons.If the share that daughters get is equal to or bigger than boys, then there is a violation of Islamic law.The provisions of Islamic law written in the Islamic Koran and KHI as guidelines for Islamic law in Indonesia show that the share of boys is greater than that of Daughter, which, when compared, becomes 2:1.
Angkola custom has been discussed previously by Raja Ritonga and Martua Nasution with the title "The Inheritance System of the Angkola Batak Muslim Society in a Review of the Qur'an (Comparative Study 10Wahyuziaulaq Wahyu and Ahmad Azmi Perkasa Alam, "Interfaith Marriage Perspective of Fiqh Law and Positive Law," NUSANTARA: Journal Of Law Studies 1, no. 1 (December 16, 2022): 33-39.

Table 2 .
Share of inheritance for daughter The Angkola Batak tribe has a kinship relationship with the Toba Batak and Mandailing Batak clans.The Angkola Batak and the Angkola Batak have their objects if it is said that the Angkola Batak means a broad customary area in the Southern Part of Tapanuli.If it is And if a daughter demands the inheritance of her parent's house in her own right, then according to the beliefs and provisions of the PersonalInterview, on 20 August 2022, Time: 15.24 WIB.